In its more subtle occurrences, this fallacy can undermine the reliability of otherwise valid deductive arguments. The fallacy of accident begins with the statement of some principle that is true as a general rule, but then errs by applying this principle to a specific case that is unusual or atypical in some way. Each of these fallacies of presumption has premises that assume one of the very things that is supposed to be proved in the conclusion. A fallacy of ambiguity, where the ambiguity in question arises directly from the poor grammatical structure in a sentence. Terms are ambiguous when it is unclear how to interpret them. My brain is a part of the universe, so the cosmos is a. Ambiguity is a concept that can be understood descriptively e. Premises are presented that are unclear enough to allow for more than one conclusion. The chapter on amphiboly takes up the question of whether ambiguous grammatical constructions are fallacious, that is part of an erroneous argument. Learn fallacies philosophy ambiguity with free interactive flashcards. A formal fallacy, deductive fallacy, logical fallacy or non sequitur latin for it does not follow is a flaw in the structure of a deductive argument which renders the argument invalid. However, sometimes ambiguity is used deliberately to add humor to a text. The fallacy was coined by antony flew in his book thinking about thinking.
Ambiguity leads to the fallacy of equivocation, which will be defined. An amphiboly can occur even when every term in an argument is univocal, if the grammatical construction of a sentence creates its own ambiguity. Equivocation is the use of expressions of double meaning in order to mislead. This can lead us to draw erroneous conclusions from given premises. Instead of using the same word with multiple meanings, as with the fallacy of equivocation, the fallacy of amphiboly involves the use of sentences which can be interpreted in multiple ways with equal justification due to some defect in the grammar, sentence structure, and. The fallacy of ambiguity is when a single term is used in two or more different ways in the same argument. Pdf using conversation policies to solve problems of ambiguity. Therefore, oprah winfrey earns less than male talkshow hosts. Coauthored by gabriel weinberg, ceo of duckduckgo and an advisor to the school of thought, it explains over 300 mental models with surprising clarity. While not always a fallacy, ambiguity can be misleading and is sometimes a logical boobytrap. Ambiguity pronounced ambigyouittee is the presence of two or more possible meanings in a single passage.
Fallacies of ambiguity, like equivocation and amphiboly, arise in arguments. Common logical fallacies insufficient or inadequate information poses the greatest threat to the integrity of an argument, but even with adequate material to support it an argument can fail because of structural weaknesses and counterfeit strategies. The fallacy of ambiguity refers to the use of a double meaning or an unclear descriptive applied to mislead or misrepresent the truth. Fallacies of equivocation arise from one word or phrase that is used with different meanings.
Equivocation is the use of expressions of double meaning in order. Other terms used for ambiguity are amphibologia, amphibolia, and semantic ambiguity in addition, ambiguity is sometimes regarded as a fallacy. Unfortunate phrasing is often responsible for unintentional humor. This fallacy is committed when a key word or phrase is used with two or more different meanings in the same argument. This fallacy is committed when the person in question is not a legitimate authority on the subject. Choose from 500 different sets of fallacies philosophy ambiguity flashcards on quizlet. The ambiguity allows the stubborn mind to redefine things at will. The fallacy of accent occurs when emphasis is used to suggest a meaning different from the actual content of the proposition. Ambiguity, or fallacy of ambiguity, is a word, phrase, or statement which contains more than one meaning.
You used a double meaning or ambiguity of language to mislead or misrepresent the truth. This can create statements which are both compelling and incorrect, either by accident or by design. Recognizing fallaciesfallacies of ambiguity wikiversity. Fallacies of ambiguity these fallacies typically occur in an argument using ambiguous words or phrases, whose meaning shifts and changes to various degrees of subtlety during the course of the argument. The intended meaning of a syntactically ambiguous phrase can generallyalthough not. The argument is then flawed because what is true of one use of the term may not be true of the other use of the term. Ambiguous words or statements lead to vagueness and confusion, and shape the basis for instances of unintentional humor. A defect in an argument other than a false premise that causes an unjustified inference non sequitur it does not follow. Intentional ambiguity is the use of language or images to suggest more than one meaning at the same time, esp.
This is committed when a person advances an argument that. Ambiguity occurs when it is unclear which meaning of a term is intended in a given context. As a logical fallacy, ambiguity occurs when linguistic ambiguity causes an argument to appear cogent when it is not. C this is a first step toward clarifying things, but there are still many ambiguities. It is this kind of shift or ambiguity in the meaning of a word or phrase in an argument that is characteristic of the fallacy of equivocation. The fallacy of accent, also known as the fallacy of emphasis, is one of the original fallacies described by aristotle, the first philosopher to systematically categorize and describe logical errors like this. Equivocation an equivocation trades upon the use of an ambiguous word or phrase in one of its meanings in one of the propositions of an argument but also in another of its meanings in a second proposition. Appeal to force accept my conclusion or ill hurt you. The fallacy occurs when a bad argument relies on the grammatical ambiguity to sound strong and logical. Suppressed, ignored, or unconsidered evidence can invalidate conclusions. Any validating form of categorical syllogism 3 with an ambiguous middle term. The fallacy of accent also prosody, accentus, misleading accent occurs when the meaning of a text is changed by what word or words are stressed, and either 1 a word different than the authors intent is stressed or 2 its unknown which word should be stressed. Presumption, ambiguity, grammatical analogy lorado. Bill clintons i did not have sexual relations with that woman, miss lewinsky.
The flaw can neatly be expressed in standard system of logic. Logical fallacies are like tricks or illusions of thought, and theyre often very sneakily used by politicians and the media to fool people. Ambiguity meaning in the cambridge english dictionary. In this section, we will look at some inductive types of arguments where the premises. The ambiguity, however, can be clearly avoided if the phrase in the auditorium is placed immediately after lecture instead of heart attack. These were arguments where the premises strongly supported the conclusion, but the support was not so strong as the necessitate or guarantee the conclusion. An appeal to authority is a fallacy with the following form.
In addition to the fallacies of relevance and presumption we examined in our previous lessons, there are several. That is, an argument that contains the same word or phrase in two premises, but the word is intended in one sense one place and another sense in the. This website has been designed to help you identify and call out dodgy logic wherever it. Fallacy of relevance, fallacy of ambiguity, and fallacy of weak induction are all examples of. This category is up of problems concerning purposeful or accidental vagueness. Introduction to ambiguity philosophy 431 october 15, 2015. The fallacies of ambiguity all involve a confusion of two or more different senses. A fallacy is basically a belief which is mistaken because of failure in reasoning and usually ends up making an unsound argument thats not valid. The fallacy of accent also referred to as accentus, or misleading accent is a type of ambiguity that arises when the meaning of a sentence is changed by placing an unusual verbal emphasis or when, in a written passage, it is left unclear on which word the emphasis was supposed to fall.
Different types of fallacies of ambiguity explained with. Accent, however, was more of a fallacy in aristotles native greek than it is for english speakers today. In addition to the fallacies of relevance and presumption we examined in our previous lessons, there are several patterns of incorrect reasoning that arise from the imprecise use of language. I want to have myself a merry little christmas, but i refuse to do as the song suggests and make the yuletide gay. The meaning of a word or set of words may be drastically changed by the way they are spoken, without changing the words themselves. Chapter 3, tutorial 4 fallacies of ambiguity there are lots of real reasoning problems when it comes to unclear language. The fallacy of accent also referred to as accentus, from its latin denomination, and misleading accent is a type of ambiguity that arises when the meaning of a sentence is changed by placing an unusual prosodic stress, or when, in a written passage, it is left unclear. Vagueness, equivocationsemantic fallacy, euphemisms, amphiboly, accent and the fallacies of analogy composition and division. It is said that we have a good understanding of our universe. Present premises that are logically irrelevant to the conclusion but which are psychologically persuasive. This can happen when an ambiguous word or phrase occurs more than once in an argument and has different meanings in two or more occurrences.
An ambiguous word, phrase, or sentence is one that has two or more distinct meanings. A fallacy of ambiguity is a flaw of logic, where the meaning of a statement is not entirely clear. The word comes from a latin term which means, wandering about and the adjective form of the word is ambiguous. Most ambiguity is logically harmless, and a fallacy occurs only when ambiguity causes an argument to appear cogent when it is not. In order to understand the difference between fallacy of relevance, fallacy of weak induction, and fallacy of ambiguity we should define fallacy.
Fallacies of ambiguity and grammatical analogy humanities. A fallacy of ambiguity occurs when a conclusion is drawn from premises that are unclear. A defect in the form or structure of a deductive argument. When an unclear premise is used, it may not support the conclusion. Logical fallacy informal fallacy ambiguity equivocation ambiguous middle term 2 fourterm fallacy syllogistic fallacy formal fallacy logical fallacy form. Fallacy of amphiboly ambiguity fallacy due to grammar.
261 832 273 491 1036 27 1281 1051 1551 807 82 938 1226 325 579 188 1549 1379 554 1247 1109 414 1323 147 683 1540 1408 465 90 445 1129 742 581 1285 753 215 1231 152 412 953 200 158 1144 1041 639 606 1096 1391